November 15, 2026

Judges 4:1-7
Matthew 25:14-30

Can a woman lead? Well, according to the fourth chapter of Judges, the answer is: yes.

Yes.

This sermon could be over right now.

That would be nice.

But.

UN Women, a United Nations agency, issued a report this year on Progress on the Sustainable Development Goals. It includes these words: “From 2019 to 2024, 99 legal reforms across 47 countries removed discriminatory laws and strengthened legal frameworks for gender equality. Mostly related to employment and economic benefits, they included statutes for equal pay, the removal of restrictions on women in some jobs, non-discrimination in hiring, and ownership or inheritance rights. Yet today, no country achieves a perfect score on all four areas measured by SDG (Sustainable Development Goals) indicator 5.1.1 (Area 1; overarching legal frameworks and public life, Area 2; violence against women, Area 3; employment and economic benefits, Area 4; marriage and family). Of 131 countries, 51% show gaps in each area. Globally, women hold only 64% of the legal rights that men enjoy.”

Listen to those last two numbers. Half of 131 countries show gaps in gender equality. Globally, women hold only 64% of the legal rights of men.

The report warns about slowing progress toward gender equality, and I can point to areas of distinct regression. One is the removal of female senior officers in the US military. It’s a matter of some satisfaction to me, actually, that an admiral who was dismissed was just elected to the US House of Representatives. It’s embarrassing to me that religion in general, and Christianity in particular, has a long record of discouraging gender equality in society and in church leadership. State of Clergywomen in the US, which came out in 2017, noted that “In 1960 women were 2.3% of U.S. clergy. In 2016 women are 20.7% of U.S. clergy.” In that year, only two American denominations had roughly equal numbers of male and female ordained leaders, the Unitarian Universalist Association and the United Church of Christ.

At the same time, however, other Christian denominations have moved in the opposite direction. The Southern Baptist Convention notably has expelled congregations – large and significant congregations – with women as pastors. The doctrine of complementarianism, which has grown in recent years, declares that God created men and women with equal worth and dignity but with distinctly different roles in life. And, surprise, surprise, the leadership roles all get reserved for men.

So no, this isn’t going to be a short sermon.

Considering this section of the book of Judges, Sara Koenig writes at Working Preacher, “…[a] noteworthy point in this lectionary selection is God’s use of a woman to lead the Israelites. Deborah is the only female judge, and she is also a prophet. She hears and speaks for God… Deborah is an example of someone who seems to put her gifts to work in surprising, creative, and inspiring ways.”

We’re not actually sure she was married. It’s a translation challenge. As Lisa Wolfe writes at Working Preacher, “While all English translations call her ‘wife of Lappidoth,’ that Hebrew phrase could also be translated ‘woman of fire,’ which aligns with her actions in this passage. The fiery warrior Deborah has an assistant named Barak, reluctant despite his name, which means ‘lightning.’”

The authors of Judges say that Deborah “was judging Israel.” This took place some time before Israel adopted a monarchy. That formula, “judging Israel,” is the same one the book uses for every other person who exercised an authority that clearly included deciding disputes, but also directing the actions of tribal leaders, appointing subordinates, and organizing the army. I think it’s fair to think of these judges as exercising the powers of monarchs in a somewhat limited way. For one thing, the authority wasn’t hereditary. The child of a judge didn’t automatically become a judge. It also seems as if most day-to-day governing was done by tribal leaders and village elders, not the national-level judges. That’s something that continued into the monarchy, by the way. If I compare the powers of King Solomon with Judge Deborah, they’re very much the same.

Deborah was judging Israel, which meant that the years-long occupation of their lands and oppression of their people was her responsibility. She assessed the situation, she considered her options, she counted her resources. She summoned a man named Barak to be the leader of the army on the field.

These were the actions of a capable and committed political leader.

As Sara Koenig noted, she spoke on God’s behalf. She acted as a prophet. She wasn’t the only judge to do so (that may have been one of the things people expected in a judge). Samuel, whom we know best as a prophet, was also Israel’s last ruling judge.

She gave Barak strategic instructions for the organization and position of the army. She also assured him of God’s direction and protection for the army, its general, and its nation.

The lectionary editors ended the passage there, but I think it’s interesting that Barak told Deborah that it was important that she come with the army. Deborah agreed, but also added that God would give the Canaanite general Sisera into the hands of a woman.

Spoiler alert: That’s what happened. Deborah and Barak’s army defeated Sisera’s army. Sisera fled on foot and tried to hide in the tent of a Kenite family. The woman of the family, named Jael, apparently sympathized with the Israelites rather than the Canaanites, because she dosed him to sleep with milk and killed him.

It’s not a pretty story. It’s not the kind of thing that I think Jesus would like.

But you know, it’s something a man would do.

Can a woman lead?

The authors of Judges thought so. As James Limburg writes at Working Preacher, “Finally, while other judges have their failures as well as successes (Gideon tended toward idolatry, 8:27, Samson was a womanizer), the biblical judgment on Deborah is uniformly positive, identifying [her] as a ‘mother in Israel’ (5:7).”

I’m not going to pretend that the Bible bears witness to a lot of women in leadership. It certainly doesn’t say that any woman can lead. But then, it doesn’t say that any man could lead, either. Male leadership in the Scriptures tends to be uneven. Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob had their faults, and so did Moses, Aaron, and Joshua. So did the monarchs that followed the judges. So did the prophets who tried to guide the kings. So did the disciples of Jesus. So did the apostles who built Jesus’ church.

Women in leadership in Scripture tend to be as or more effective than their male counterparts, and most of them don’t have as much baggage. Women have been extraordinarily capable leaders not just in the Biblical accounts, but also in other cultures. Hatshepsut ruled in Egypt just over 1400 years before Jesus’ birth. Elizabeth I of England unified a nation torn by the religious conflicts of the early Tudors and withstood a foreign invasion attempt. Lili’uokalani attempted to restore the vote to the poorer people of Hawai’i, and only failed because she was betrayed by the ministers of her own government.

The list goes on.

Can a woman lead?

Yes. Assuredly yes. We’ve repeatedly seen that it’s yes. Over and over again, it’s been yes.

So why is this even a question? Why should anyone think that my opinion, as a man, was even relevant to the question?

Because men have been remarkably successful in seizing authority and maintaining it for centuries, even millennia. They’ve asserted that there are virtues associated with the simple fact of maleness – courage, integrity, wisdom, power – that are not associated with femaleness. They further assert that virtues associated with the simple fact of femaleness – compassion, empathy, reconciliation – are not useful virtues for leadership. Leadership, they assert, requires forceful virtues.

Hogwash. Balderdash. Nonsense. Add the appropriate descriptive noun or nouns of your choice.

Judges attributes courage, integrity, wisdom, and power to Deborah. Compassion, empathy, and reconciliation are virtues the New Testament ascribes to Jesus.

So can a woman lead? In church? In school? In a legislature? In a home? In a medical practice? Can a woman lead a nation? A state? A county? A service club? A political party? A helping agency? A utility? A trade union? A plumbing company?

Can a woman lead?

Yes. Oh, yes. I wish I could have the last word on it, but yes. Always yes. Ever yes.

A woman can lead. Yes.

Amen.

by Eric Anderson

Watch the Recorded Sermon

Pastor Eric prepares the sermon ahead of time, but he makes changes while preaching. The sermon as prepared does not precisely match the sermon as presented.

The image is Deborah Beneath the Palm Tree by James Tissot (between 1896 and 1902), Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=8860152.

Leave a Reply