During the Exodus, God intervened to help Moses solve his leadership problem: by adding additional leaders.
Here’s a transcript:
I’m thinking about the eleventh chapter of Numbers (Numbers 11:4-6, 10-16, 24-29). This is a part of the Exodus story, where so many of the events seem to follow this general pattern:
The people of Israel out there in the wild come to Moses with a problem.
Moses panics and prays to God that horrible things are happening and why on earth did you ever do this to me?
And then God fixes it.
And that’s pretty much what we have here. The people were hungry. They came to Moses. They said, “We are tired of manna” (miraculous food… I guess you’d get tired of it). Moses went to God and said, Why did you do this to me? Did I give birth to this people that you expect me to take care of them?”
Now, usually at this point in the story, I’d be telling you about what God did in order to relieve the initial problem. But this time, God did something different (later, God did fix the initial problem). Before that, however, God said, Moses, you’re absolutely right. You cannot carry this people all by yourself as if they were a child and you were their mother. You need help.
And so seventy elders were appointed to become a leadership team with Moses. Sixty-eight of them reported for the initial time in which God and Moses would commission them to their work. Two of them, however, were missing: yet even they responded to the presence of the Spirit of God by declaring God’s grace and mercy in the other places in the camp where they were. When people told Moses that they were doing it, Moses replied, finally seeing the wisdom of additional leadership, “Would that everyone would prophesy.”
We tend to think of leadership as being the acts of a single person. There isn’t much substitute, actually, for somebody to step out, to have a vision, to encourage people to participate in it, join it, and support it. There also isn’t a substitute for other leadership. A single person cannot do it all, and particularly not as the group of people they’re leading gets larger. We all have our roles to play as we gather with other people in order to accomplish significant things, whether that be in a family, whether that be in a social group, whether that be in a workplace, whether that be in the Church.
Find your place and role for that particular activity. Because at one moment you might be the senior leader in one group, you might find yourself a junior leader at the same time in another group. And later on you might find yourself being the one who carries on with the work and supports the other leaders to make God’s grace and love and mercy known.
That’s what I’m thinking. I’m curious to hear what you’re thinking. Leave me your thoughts in the comment section below. I’d love to hear from you.
If you search Biblegateway.com for the word “shepherd” in the New Revised Standard Version of the Bible, you get 109 uses. I’m afraid that some of those appear in the occasional subheadings that modern-day editors have helpfully added, so the original numbers are somewhat lower. Still. 87 uses in the Old Testament, 22 in the New Testament. “Shepherd” is an important word.
One of the reasons for that was the cultural self-image of the Hebrew people. They saw themselves as shepherd people, those who followed the flocks of sheep and goats and therefore spent relatively little time in a fixed abode. Somewhat like the rivalry between the farmer and the cowhand in the Rogers and Hammerstein musical Oklahoma. Do you remember the song “The Farmer and the Cowhand Should Be Friends,” which basically feeds the bad feeling between them? Well, the shepherds were the ancient equivalent of cowhands, and the farmers and city dwellers of the eastern Mediterranean had a similar rivalry.
A fair number of those “shepherd” references in the Old Testament are variants on, “We’re shepherd people, and that’s the best thing to be.”
The Israelites also liked the image of “shepherd” for their national leaders. It might refer to priests or senior civic officials, but the favorite reference was to the king. David, of course, made the metaphor obvious, since as Psalm 78 says,
“He chose his servant David and took him from the sheepfolds; from tending the nursing ewes he brought him to be the shepherd of his people Jacob, of Israel, his inheritance. With upright heart he tended them and guided them with skillful hand.”
– Psalm 78
The one who really liked to compare kings to shepherds was Jeremiah. He used “shepherd” nineteen times, more than any other book of the Bible. And nearly always, he used it as we’ve heard it this morning. “Woe to the shepherds who destroy and scatter the sheep of my pasture! says the LORD.”
Jeremiah really didn’t have a high opinion of the kings of his day. Or a mediocre opinion. Low opinion is… getting close. He thought they were awful.
He did, however, provide us with an admirable summary of what a monarch, or a leader, should do and be: “he shall reign as king and deal wisely and shall execute justice and righteousness in the land.” As we come up to our primary election, with the likelihood that a number of our state and county races will be decided by this ballot, I humbly suggest that you vote for the candidates who display the attributes of wisdom and have the capacity and desire to execute justice and righteousness in the land. If they don’t… vote for somebody else.
I do know that every four years, (with a tear-drop more anxiety this time around) I want to believe verse four –
“I will raise up shepherds over them who will shepherd them, and they shall no longer fear or be dismayed, nor shall any be missing, says God.”
even knowing that the Holy One, is looking right at me to be less of a hand-wringer, and take responsibility for the raising-up.
But if you want a real shepherd, the place to look is the sixth chapter of Mark.
Earlier in the chapter, Jesus commissioned his disciples to widen his work, dispatching them about the villages and towns to teach and to heal. As they did so, word came to Jesus, and to the people of Galilee, that John the Baptist had been executed by King Herod. When the disciples returned, still excited about their success, Jesus took them off to go on retreat. They needed a break. They needed to tell their stories. They needed to do some grieving for John the Baptist, whose ministry still influenced them all.
Instead, they found a crowd had anticipated them and arrived before they did.
As Cheryl Lindsay writes at UCC.org, “Mark seems the least concerned with character development. We find out who Jesus and his disciples are by what they do and what they teach. Yet, even in this account, Jesus does a remarkable thing by prioritizing rest in the midst of impactful ministry and gathering crowds. This time, it is not his own rest, which he has already modeled as a spiritual practice. Jesus is as concerned with his disciples adopting a routine of rest within the rhythm of their coming and going.”
Jesus “had compassion for them, because they were like sheep without a shepherd, and he began to teach them many things.”
It has always impressed me that Jesus, despite his need and his disciples’ need of time to themselves, gave that up in order to serve the people who needed more. As we’ve been reading Mark’s Gospel this year, I’ve been struck by the number of times this happened to Jesus, that he tried to take time away and couldn’t. It’s a minor theme of the gospel, but it’s there. Jesus didn’t have a lot of luck taking time off.
I’m also struck by the appearance of that word, “shepherd.” As Matt Skinner writes at Working Preacher, “‘The system’ has failed the people who flock to Jesus, as evidenced in Herod Antipas’s lethal fecklessness (6:14–29).2 They are vulnerable in a predatory world. No one, it seems, guards their human dignity. They have to fend for themselves. What kind of society places people in that kind of condition?”
I hate to say it, but a lot of human societies do precisely that, and explain it away as… the way things are.
Jesus, however, seeing people in need of leadership, stepped in to provide it. That’s what you’d expect of a Messiah, come to think of it. A Messiah is a leader, a general, a king. “Let’s get together, people! Form up in ranks. To Herod’s palace, march!”
Only… he didn’t do that. At all.
He taught them. Remember what Jeremiah said a shepherd does? Deal wisely? Jesus is a shepherd who teaches wisdom.
I have to assume that some of the people on the beach came seeking healing, because that’s nearly always the case in Mark. Later in the chapter, when Jesus and his disciples, probably still looking for that private retreat, landed near Gennesaret, it was abundantly clear. They brought the sick out to the marketplace. They reached out to touch the fringe of his cloak, just like that woman with the hemorrhage. They were healed.
I say this a lot. People are impressed with power, with glamor, with fame. We tend to defer to people with those things whether their ideas are good, indifferent, bad, or downright horrid. Why, I wonder, don’t we value leadership like that displayed by Jesus? Why do we vote for the self-aggrandizing and power hungry, rather than the wise and the compassionate?
Jesus stepped onto the shore from the boat and saw the vacuum of power, the dearth of governmental concern, the absence of good shepherding. He saw a need. Then he filled it.
But he didn’t fill it with glitz. He didn’t fill it with glamor. He didn’t fill it with the coercive power which is a government’s most treasured privilege. He filled it with wisdom, with compassion, and with healing. Oh, and bread. That first beach they landed on, the one where Jesus saw them without a shepherd? At the end of the day Jesus fed all five thousand of them with five loaves and two fish.
Now that’s a shepherd. There’s one who really cares for the sheep.
Not all of us will take positions of leadership in society. There’s not room for everyone to be mayor, or governor, or president. There’s not even room for everyone to be pastor, or moderator, or a member of one of our governing boards of this church – though I will say that there is definitely room, and the nominating committee is hard at work to find those shepherds of our congregation for the next year.
Jesus didn’t commission his disciples to become mayors or governors or presidents or monarchs, or to be their supporters. He didn’t commission them to become generals or courtiers. He commissioned them to be apostles, teachers and healers. He commissioned them to be the same kind of shepherd that he was.
That is our summons, too. To follow Jesus as people who value and share wisdom, who do our level best to provide healing, who refrain from the acts that divide people and scatter them so that they are no longer cared for.
Because we are cared for by the one who is a true shepherd, guiding us in wisdom, justice, and righteousness, all the days of our lives. That’s a shepherd.
Amen.
by Eric Anderson
Watch the Recorded Sermon
Pastor Eric sometimes ventures away from his prepared text. He hopes he’s improving things.
When using shepherds as a metaphor, we often think of leaders and rulers. But when Jesus acted like a shepherd, he fed people.
Here’s a transcript:
I’m thinking about portions of the sixth chapter of the Gospel of Mark (Mark 6:30-34, 53-56). There are two stories that don’t actually have a lot of content to them: Jesus arrived somewhere and found a crowd waiting (or one had followed him), and then he taught them.
As we’ve been reading through the Gospel of Mark so far this year, I’ve been aware of a sub-theme I don’t think I’ve noticed before: how Jesus keeps on looking for a day off, and not getting one. And indeed, in the first of these stories Jesus comes along, a crowd follows him, and Jesus “had compassion on them because they were like sheep without a shepherd.”
Now, shepherd is a multi layered metaphor in the scriptures of Christians and Jews. the Hebrew people in the Psalms frequently used the metaphor of shepherds to refer to a ruler. They also, of course, famously used it to refer to God in Psalm 23. The Messiah that was promised? Well, all the shepherding imagery that came with that related to that same image of shepherd as guide, as leader, as ruler. Sheep need to be led.
But when Jesus found people waiting for him, or when Jesus found the people who had followed him, and he saw them as sheep without a shepherd, his response was not to tell them what to do. His response was to feed them: to feed them upon the word of God, to feed them on actual food (the lectionary has left out the feeding of the 5000, but that’s actually one of the stories that lies between these two passages). Jesus proceeded to see that the people he met were fed.
We’ve been thinking of shepherding all wrong.
We’ve been thinking of shepherding as the exercise of power. We’ve been thinking of shepherding as the exercise of guidance. We’ve been thinking of shepherding as, “I lead. You follow.”
But the shepherd that God gave us, the Good Shepherd that God gave us, was one to make sure that we were cared for, that we were fed, that we were whole.
That’s what I’m thinking. I’m curious to hear what you’re thinking. Leave me your thoughts in the comment section below. I’d love to hear from you.
Stories of prophetic transition – when responsibility for the task of speaking God’s messages passes from one prophet to another – are rare in the Bible. The closest parallel in the Old Testament is the transition from Moses to Joshua as the Hebrew people prepared to leave the desert and enter the Promised Land. Indeed, we find that story echoed here, as Elijah and Elisha – the mentor prophet and the successor prophet – made Joshua’s journey in reverse, crossing the River Jordan to exit the Promised Land before Elijah’s mantle fell on his successor’s shoulders.
One problem we face in this story is that the names of the two main characters sound almost identical. Elijah was the elder of the two men. He was well known in the northern kingdom of Israel as a thorn in the side of Israel’s monarchs. He had had great moments of triumph, and he had had sad occasions of failure. After a great success in persuading Israel’s King Ahab of God’s power through the ending of a drought, he had fled from the wrath of Queen Jezebel, resulting in his visit to the mountain of Horeb and God’s unhappy question, “What are you doing here, Elijah?”
There at Horeb God had additional tasks for Elijah, and one of them was to appoint Elisha as prophet in his – Elijah’s – place. Elisha has an “sh” in it, which sounds a lot like a “j,” and I’m afraid there’s not much I can do about that except to say one is younger and one is older. A lot.
The authors of First and Second Kings weren’t clear how long Elijah and Elisha worked together. From the way they described Elisha’s, the younger’s, reactions in this story, it sounds like it was long enough for the younger prophet to develop a deep relationship with the older. His cry of “My father” as his mentor was swept away sounds like a deep cry of grief.
The account really focuses on Elisha, the younger one, doesn’t it? He gets the best lines: “As the LORD lives, and as you yourself live, I will not leave you.” The various other prophets they meet come to him, not to his teacher, to tell him about his impending loss. “Yes, I know; keep silent.” All the emotionality of this story as it’s told concentrates on Elisha, the younger one, right up to the point where he tore his clothes in grief. As Steed Davidson writes at Working Preacher, “Clearly Elisha would prefer to have his master remain. His clinging onto Elijah as they travel may look pathetic but reveals the intimacy of their relationship, one that transcends the conventional father-son relationship of a prophet with his students (verse 12).”
But. That’s not how it struck me this month. I’m feeling just a little bit more like Elijah, the senior, the mentor, the one whose time is drawing to its close. When you’ve got to go, you’ve got to go.
That’s not because I’ve had any bad medical diagnoses, by the way, and although somebody asked me not too long ago about a rumor that I’m soon to be called away from Hilo, that’s not happening either. I’ve developed a sabbatical plan that will have me absent from pastoral responsibilities for three months in 2025. The sabbatical commits me to remain with Church of the Holy Cross for three years after that. So. I’m not anticipating Elijah’s whirlwind.
I confess that feeling ill for so many days, however, has me considering my own mortality. Ash Wednesday comes up this week, and I hear its refrain, “Remember you are dust, and to dust you will return.” “You turn us back to dust and say, ‘Turn back, you mortals,’” wrote the poet in Psalm 90. “So teach us to count our days that we may gain a wise heart.”
For any of us, the boundary between this life and the next lies in a place we do not and cannot know. It might be years away, and it might be tomorrow.
It’s not just mortality, though. I’m serving as advisor to a Member in Discernment of the Hawai’i Island Association. If you’re not familiar with phrase, that’s someone who is in the process that leads toward ordination in the United Church of Christ. It’s not the first time. Ironically, one of my previous advisees has already retired. Another serves a church in Connecticut. A young man I worked with in a youth group many years ago asked me to bring the charge to him at his ordination. There have been others.
I’m deeply aware that this advisee will mostly likely continue his career in the Church when mine has reached its end. Part of my responsibility as his advisor is to help him bring out his best so that the Church he serves – the congregations and the wider Body of Christ – receive the full blessing of his gifts. I’m not just supporting him and the congregation he currently serves – he’s a licensed pastor at this time – I’m supporting the Church that I may never see.
I can’t make that happen alone. It’s up to those who follow me as well. As Debie Thomas writes at JourneyWithJesus.net, “Elisha’s salvation comes in the long silence after the glory. It comes when he still has no idea whether Elijah’s ‘double portion’ of God’s spirit will rest on him, or not. It comes when he chooses to stand up, shoulder his grief, take up his teacher’s mantle, and cross the threshold into a new and unfamiliar life.”
Spoiler alert: Elisha – the successor – did take up the mantle, and he did find himself with a “double portion” of his mentor’s spirit. Jason Byassee observes at Working Preacher, “The rabbis count Elijah doing eight miracles in scripture and Elisha 16. Double. The transition from a beloved elder to a new and untested younger doesn’t have to be a loss. It can be a gain, a doubling, a greater portion.”
The transition can be a gain, even when it’s from me, or from you.
Thirty-six years ago in seminary, I had a complaint. I felt then – and continue to feel now – that I received training for a church and social environment that was already shifting, which if it still existed at all would cease to exist pretty soon. Seminaries have struggled to address that massive change with a little success and a lot of failure. My own alma mater merged with another Divinity School in 2017. Seminaries I considered attending have ceased to offer the Master of Divinity degree. It’s been rather depressing.
My first call was to two congregations in neighboring towns in Maine. One of those churches closed its doors years ago. The other churches I’ve served continue to worship and minister, but I spent seventeen years on the staff of a conference – which merged with two other conferences a few years ago. The simple truth is that membership in UCC congregations has been declining throughout my career, and we are not alone. The percentage of United States residents who are found on the membership lists of communities of faith is just under half.
So I wonder how I, as Elijah the elder prophet, can support those who will almost certainly have to build new ways to encourage and nurture disciples, to equip them with what they need in order to do God’s work, and to assist them as long as possible along the rugged roads of the journey? How can I, and how can we as a congregation, both recognize that the future will be different from the present, but that it must be in order for the Gospel’s power to be better revealed? How can we experiment, and learn from success and failure, and pass on the word that these are the things we haven’t tried? How can we approach the banks of the Jordan River with our successors at our side and endorse their prayers for a double helping of our spirit?
Those of you wearing Elisha’s, the younger one’s, shoes – you’ll have to help us with this. You may have noticed that people tend to think that what once worked always will work, even when it hasn’t worked for some time. Mind you, your ideas might not work either, but bring them. If things are going to fail, let’s fail in new ways.
And if you, like me, are wearing Elijah’s, the older one’s, shoes, well: can we bring Elijah’s grace to these times of transition? Can we let our successors follow along even though we’re not sure it will be good for them? Can we let ourselves step away from what we’ve always done and always had responsibility for because it’s their kuleana now? Can we face the sorrow and loss of the whirlwind with hope and confidence in those we leave behind?
Because when you’ve got to go, you’ve got to go.
Amen.
by Eric Anderson
Watch the Recorded Sermon
Pastor Eric does make changes to his prepared text while preaching. Sometimes he makes those changes deliberately, and sometimes not.
The image is The Prophet Elijah − the 17th century icon, provenance − Weremień. Now in the Historic Museum in Sanok, Poland. Photo by Janmad – Own work, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=9385535.
What happens when responsibility and leadership passes from one generation to another? Hopefully, a double portion of the spirit – but also grief.
Here’s a transcript:
This coming Sunday is the last one before the beginning of Lent. That makes it Transfiguration Sunday. I am not, however, thinking about the ninth chapter of Mark. I’ve been thinking and preaching about the Transfiguration story almost every year for the last few years. Instead, I’m thinking about the second chapter of Second Kings (2 Kings 2:1-12), which is Elisha’s farewell to Elijah.
One could wish that the two prophets had names that were more different from one another, so that you could keep them apart. Elijah was the older of the two. He had been significantly engaged with the monarchs of Israel, particularly in trying (with some success and a good deal of failure) to encourage King Ahab and Queen Jezebel to rule more faithfully. Elisha was the younger one. He would have been Elijah’s student. It was clearly understood by the two of them that it when it came Elijah’s turn it to retire, Elisha would be the one to succeed him.
And that’s the story in the second chapter of Second Kings.
There is something of a travelogue. They journey from one place to another. They meet groups of prophets who are apparently living together, possibly training together. They warn Elisha, the younger one, that his master will be taken from him, and he says, “I know. Be silent.”
We have all had that experience of knowing that something unpleasant, undesirable, painful, is coming and not wanting to hear it from others.
They crossed the Jordan River in another instance of the river becoming dry for long enough to cross, and Elijah asked Elisha what he would like to receive from him. Elisha asked for a double portion of Elijah’s spirit. Elijah said, “That’s a difficult thing and not mine to grant, but if you see me as God raises me from the earth, then your request will be granted.”
As it happened Elisha did see Elijah swept up from earth in a whirlwind. He fell to his knees and he tore his clothes.
We are each one of us successors to the previous prophets. We are heirs of the message. We are its bearers in our own time. And we are those who will equip another generation, or more than one generation, to bring it to yet more people after we are gone. I think Elisha’s request for a double portion of the spirit — oh, my goodness. Imagine if each of us had done that, generation after generation after generation, what would the world be like if we could dedicate ourselves to the spirit of God as Elijah did, and as Elisha did.
But also on that very human side: Even as Elisha must have rejoiced to know that he had received that double portion of the spirit, he still fell to his knees and tore his clothes, because his mentor, teacher, and friend was gone. And even with his double portion of the spirit he was in grief.
None of that changes. People depart from us, sometimes for a short time, and sometimes until we meet again in eternity.
And we do grieve.
That’s what I’m thinking. I’m curious to hear what you’re thinking. Leave me your thoughts in the comment section below. I’d love to hear from you.